More than 30 years ago, an idea was put forward that high colonic pH promoted colorectal cancer. A high colonic pH may promote the creation of carcinogens from bile acids, a process that is inhibited once you get below a pH of about 6.5. This is supported by data, showing those at higher risk for colon cancer may have a higher stool pH, and those at lower risk, a low pH. There was a dramatic difference between the two groups, with most of the high risk group over 8, and most of the low risk group under 6.
This may help explain the 50-fold lower rates of colon cancer in Africa compared to America. The bacteria we have in our gut depends on what we eat. If we eat lots of fibre then we preferentially feed the fibre eating bacteria, which give us back all sorts of health promoting substances like short-chain fatty acids that have anti-inflammatory and anti-cancer properties. More of these organic acids were found in the stools of native Africans than African Americans. More acids, so lower pH. Whereas putrefactive bacteria which eat animal protein are able to increase stool pH by producing alkaline metabolites like ammonia.
The pH of the stools of white versus black children in Africa was compared. Children, because you can more readily sample their stools, particularly the rural black schoolchildren who were eating such high fibre diets—whole grains, legumes, nuts, vegetables, fruits and wild greens—9 out of 10 could produce a stool on demand. Stuffed from head to tail with plants they could give you a stool sample at any time, as easy as getting a urine sample. Hard to even get access to the white kids, though, who were reluctant to participate in such investigations, even though they were given waxed cartons fitted with lids, and all the black kids got was a plate, and a square of paper towel.
What’d they find? Significantly lower fecal pH in those eating the traditional rural plant-based diets, compared to those eating the traditional western diet, who were eating far fewer whole plant foods than the black children. But remove some of those whole plant foods, like switch their corn for white bread for just a few days, and their stool pH goes up, and add whole plant foods like an extra 5 to 7 servings of fruit every day, and their stool pH goes down even further, gets more acidic. Makes sense, right?
What happens when you ferment plants, fruits/veggies/grains, they turn sour, like vinegars, sauerkraut, sourdough, because good bacteria like lactobacillus produce organic acids like lactic acid. And those who eat a lot of plants have more of those good bugs. So using the purple cabbage test, we want blue pee, but pink poo.
No surprise, then, if you compare the fecal samples of those eating vegetarian or vegan, to those eating standard diets, plant-based diets appear to shift the makeup of the bacteria in our gut, resulting in a significantly lower stool pH, and the more plant-based the diet, the lower the pH drops. It’s like a positive feedback loop. Fibre-eating bacteria produce the acids to create the pH at which fibre-eating bacteria thrive while suppressing the group of less beneficial bugs.
How long does it take to bring stool pH down on a plant-based diet? As little as two weeks. A dozen volunteers were carefully selected for their trustworthiness, and randomised to go on regular, vegetarian, or vegan diets sequentially and two weeks in, a significant drop in fecal pH was achieved eating completely plant-based.
But there are plant-based diets and then there are plant-based diets. Remember these two groups? Dramatically different stool pH yet both groups were vegetarian, but the high risk group was eating mostly refined grains, very little fibre, whereas the low risk group was eating whole grains and beans, packed with fibre for our fibre-friendly flora to munch on.
Just as a reduction of high serum cholesterol contributes to the avoidance of coronary heart disease, so a fall in the fecal pH value may contribute to the avoidance of bowel cancer, and through the same means, eating more whole plant foods.
REFERENCES
J Ou, F Carbonero, E G Zoetendal, J P Delany, M Wang, K Newton, H R Gaskins, S J O’Keefe. Diet, microbiota, and microbial metabolites in colon cancer risk in rural Africans and African Americans. Am J Clin Nutr. 2013 Jul;98(1):111-20.
J Maukonen, M Saarela. Human gut microbiota: does diet matter? Proc Nutr Soc. 2015 Feb;74(1):23-36.
J Zimmer, B Lange, J S Frick, H Sauer, K Zimmermann, A Schwiertz, K Rusch, S Klosterhalfen, P Enck. Eur J Clin Nutr. 2012 Jan;66(1):53-60.
W Van Dokkum, B C de Boer, A Van Faassen, N A Pikaar, R J Hermus. Diet, faecal pH and colorectal cancer. Br J Cancer. 1983 Jul; 48(1): 109–110.
J R Thornton. High colonic pH promotes colorectal cancer. Lancet. 1981 May 16;1(8229):1081-3.
A R Walker, B F Walker, I Segal. Faecal pH value and its modification by dietary means in South African black and white schoolchildren. S Afr Med J. 1979 Mar 24;55(13):495-8.
A R Walker, B F Walker. Faecal pH and colon cancer. Gut. 1992 Apr; 33(4): 572.
S L Malhotra. Faecal urobilinogen levels and pH of stools in population groups with different incidence of cancer of the colon, and their possible role in its aetiology. J R Soc Med. 1982 Sep;75(9):709-14.
Give a Reply